Elliott accumulated roughly 8% economic exposure in Mentor Graphics in September 2016. By mid-November, Mentor—which had reportedly been considering strategic options—announced an agreement for Siemens to buy it at $37.25 per share, a 21% premium to the prior Friday close, valuing the EDA software maker near $4.5 billion.

The merger fit Siemens' 'Vision 2020' push into industrial software and Industry 4.0; Mentor's roughly $1.2 billion-revenue business would join Siemens' product lifecycle management unit, with the deal expected to close in the second quarter of 2017.

Elliott's November 14, 2016 amended 13D records the mechanism: a Support Agreement with Mentor and Siemens under which Elliott agreed to vote its shares for the merger, with an irrevocable proxy if it failed to do so, and restrictions on transferring shares before the vote.

Siemens acquired Mentor at $37.25 per share (about $4.5B), a 21% premium; Elliott's 13D/A shows it signed a support agreement to vote for the merger.

The disclosed stake signaled the board could not wait out the discount.

Elliott's support agreement removed the biggest proxy risk for Siemens.

A premium cash bid answered the 'what's it worth' question fast.

A 13D that questions the standalone path shortens the runway to a sale; a written support agreement converts the activist from threat into the deal's biggest backer.

The acquisition closed in April 2017, making Mentor part of Siemens' digital industry software portfolio and giving shareholders a 21% premium; Elliott exited with a clear win in weeks rather than years.

FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE

The sources

  1. Mentor Graphics Corporation Schedule 13D/A (Amendment No. 1) — Elliott Support Agreement sec.gov
  2. Siemens pursues Industry 4.0 with Mentor Graphics buy eenewseurope.com
  3. Why Shares of Mentor Graphics Are Up Today fool.com