What was changed
On June 25, 2017 Daniel Loeb disclosed that Third Point had bought a 1.3% stake in Nestlé for $3.5 billion and sent a letter saying the company had fallen behind, urging cost cuts, the sale of non-growth businesses and the L'Oréal stake, and share buybacks (UPI).
Days later Nestlé's board approved a CHF 20 billion buyback and outlined a value-creation model built on margin improvement and capital efficiency (press release, June 27, 2017). In September 2017 it set its first margin target: 17.5-18.5% by 2020, up from 16% in 2016 (FT via Swissinfo).
Nestlé then reshaped the portfolio: it sold its US confectionery business to Ferrero for $2.8 billion in January 2018 (BBC) and completed the CHF 20 billion buyback in December 2019 (Reuters). Its underlying trading operating profit margin reached 17.6% in 2019, hitting the target a year early.
What it achieved
Nestlé completed a CHF 20B buyback, sold US confectionery to Ferrero for $2.8B, and lifted its underlying operating margin to 17.6% by 2019.
Why it worked
The letter quantified the problem: earnings per share had not grown in five years.
A visible buyback answered the criticism faster than a strategy speech.
A margin target gave management a metric to reorganize around.
Divestitures recycled low-growth brands into higher-growth categories.
What can be applied
A written outsider case about margins and capital returns can shift a consumer giant's priorities; Nestlé kept its growth ambitions but adopted the returns it had long resisted.
Aftermath
Nestlé kept the capital-return model: it launched a second CHF 20 billion buyback program in 2020 and continued pruning the portfolio. Third Point later exited, but the margin discipline and returns survived the activist.
FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE
The sources
- Nestlé press release, June 27, 2017 — value creation model and CHF 20 billion buyback (Internet Archive copy) web.archive.org
- UPI — Daniel Loeb's Third Point buys $3.5B in Nestle stocks for 1.3 percent stake upi.com
- BBC — Nestle sells Crunch, Nerds and other US brands to Ferrero for $2.8bn bbc.com
- Fiji Times (Reuters) — Nestle wraps up 20 billion Swiss franc share buyback, launches new program fijitimes.com.fj